For best results, pound your chicken thighs using a meat tenderizer, then sprinkle on taco seasoning and salt. Spray the Instant Pot with cooking oil spray and then add in ½ T olive oil. Then set the Instant Pot to saute and, working in batches, sear the chicken thighs, adding in an additional ½ T of olive oil, as needed. With the last batch, add garlic and saute for an additional minute.
Add all chicken thighs to the pot. Mix lime juice, orange juice, and chicken broth and pour over chicken. Lock your lid.
Then set your IP for 15 minutes on manual pressure. After cooktime, do a 6 minute natural pressure release before doing a quick release. Stir in cilantro and shred chicken.
Optional - if you like spicy/smoky carnitas, add 1-2 teaspoons (or more) of chopped chipotle peppers in adobo sauce after cooktime. They come in a can and they are super spicy, so just add a small amount to start. The flavor is really delicious with the citrus and taco seasoning, but it's not for everyone!
If you want a crispier meat, it's very simple to use your Mealthy CrispLid or Ninja Foodi to Crisp your Carnitas for a few minutes before serving! This is actually one of my FAV ways to use my CrispLid!
OR Preheat your broiler to high heat. Using a slotted spoon, remove carnitas from the pot and place on a greased or lined baking sheet. Drizzle with some of the cooking juice and 1 T olive oil. Broil until edges are crispy (about 5 minutes), then drizzle with more cooking juice.
Serve with Peach Salsa, red cabbage, and greek yogurt with lime (if desired)